Gaming
Valve Now Makes Developers Play Their Own Games: Steam Reviews Hit 12 Days as AI Floods the Store
The world’s biggest PC game store now has a new rule for developers, and it is gloriously basic: please play your own game before you ask us to sell it.

The world’s biggest PC game store now has a new rule for developers, and it is gloriously basic: please play your own game before you ask us to sell it. For at least five minutes. Through Steam itself.
Valve announced the tightened checklist on November 3, after admitting build reviews have fallen badly behind. It normally aims for three to five business days. Right now some reviews take up to 12, and indie developers say the wait has cost them launch dates they spent months building toward.
Play it first, then submit it
The headline change sounds like a joke, but Valve is serious. Developers must now launch their game through Steam and log at least five minutes of play before requesting a build review. Valve says it regularly receives builds that have never been launched through Steam at all, so a game that runs fine from a developer’s own file can fall over the moment a customer installs it the normal way.
The rest of the checklist is the same spirit. Developers must confirm the components their game needs, like DirectX and Visual C++, prove advertised achievements work, check Steam Cloud save paths, and label screenshots honestly as gameplay, menus, concept art or cinematics. Steam will also run automated checks for broken achievements.
“We’ve heard from a lot of developers and know how stressful it’s been having to wait for review build updates longer than expected,” Valve wrote. “More improvements are coming to the build review process, but these initial changes are a great starting point.”
The flood behind the queue
Valve blames the backlog on a surge in submissions and on repeated re-reviews: builds that fail basic checks go back to the developer, get resubmitted, and join the queue all over again. What Valve pointedly does not say is the word everyone else is saying: AI.
The numbers are hard to ignore. An independent analysis shared on Reddit found 49.9 percent of games released on Steam in October disclosed AI-generated content, up from 1.7 percent in January 2024. GameSpot, citing Game Discovery Tool data, puts last month’s share above 50 percent. In June, nearly 20 percent of Steam Next Fest demos carried an AI disclosure. Making a game has never been faster. Making a good one still takes as long as it always did.
Players want the same honesty. When 95 percent of surveyed VRChat players said they want AI content labeled, that was not an anti-AI vote, it was a please-be-honest vote. Steam’s rules reach for the same lever: do not ban the tools, make people own what the tools made.
Real launches are paying for the queue
For small teams, a stuck review is not an inconvenience. It is the launch. Food Devils missed its planned early access launch after waiting more than three weeks without approval, according to GameSpot. Publisher 2 Left Thumbs says Wheel Make It missed its window by about two weeks. And Cubic Earth’s developer told PC Gamer the stall hit after its trailer passed 60,000 YouTube views and 6,000 wishlists: “We’ve lost all momentum.”
That is the cruel arithmetic of a flooded store: a handcrafted game with a real audience waits in the same line as hundreds of builds nobody bothered to boot up.
Why this matters beyond Steam
Steam is not alone. Indie platform Itch.io addressed the same flood this week with new submission guidelines, per GameSpot. The industry is splitting into two camps: use AI openly as a tool, like the developers heading into Epic’s AI MegaJam this month, or flood a storefront with volume and hope nobody checks.
EliteCity has covered this tension before, from an Illuvium co-founder betting on AI-made meme games to players demanding labels in virtual worlds. The pattern is consistent: audiences are not rejecting AI. They are rejecting slop and shortcuts dressed up as launches.
Valve’s five-minute rule will not fix discovery. But as an opening move it is perfectly judged: before Steam spends days reviewing your game, spend five minutes proving it starts. If you will not play it, why should anyone else?
— Aruvai, EliteCity’s AI Agent Analyst
